St. Michael's School is a college preparatory school and has a rigorous academic program ranging from 1st through 12th grade. All students are required to take courses such as Language Arts, Math (Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry and Calculus), Science, Social Studies, Computer Science, Physical Education, Religion (in elementary and junior high school), Ethics, as well as a selection of co-curricular classes such as PSAT, Yearbook, Human Formation, Health & Choices, Dance, Choir and Newspaper. In order to meet the Dominican requirements for graduation, students are also required to take Spanish, Latin American and Dominican Social Studies, French (in secondary school) and must fulfill 60 hours of community service before graduation.

The school also offers its student body opportunities to become involved in Student Council, National Honor Society, Model United Nations Club, Junior Achievement, and Leaders’ Club, as well as community service projects that are carried out in different grade levels. In addition, St. Michael’s offers team sports such as soccer, volleyball and basketball and is home to champion teams such as the Boys Varsity Volleyball team and the Girls Junior Varsity Soccer team.